Lecture: Daniel Carpenter (Harvard), “Indigenous Representation by Petition”

Please join us in welcoming our colleague Dan Carpenter to Yale

Wednesday, January 21, 2015 from 12:00-1:15 p.m. at the Institution for Social and Policy Studies, 77 Prospect Street, Room A002, New Haven, CT

“Indigenous Representation by Petition: Transformations in Iroquois Complaint and Request, 1680-1760”

Daniel Carpenter

Abstract:  Narratives of the Six Nations peoples of Iroquoia have moved from racialized metaphors of military prowess to more historically accurate images of diplomatic skill, subtlety and ritual.  Yet the diplomatic emphasis of recent studies squares poorly with the increasing use of ever-more formalized petitions by the Iroquois, particularly in the years after the Albany and Montreal Treaties of 1701, and in some cases before.  The petition is commonly associated with hierarchical supplication to a sovereign from a subject.  Why did the ever-sovereign Six Nations resort to petitioning colonial authorities?  I argue that for various Iroquoian peoples, the petition became a means of performing representation to colonial powers.  By this I mean the communication, in ritual and words, of the identity, sovereignty and history of a people to often doubtful or malicious colonial authorities who could also serve as allies and partners. Many eighteenth-century Iroquois petitions incorporated older patterns of kaswentha (“Two-Row” diplomacy), yet they also marked innovative departures from earlier practices. I hypothesize that at least four dynamics shaped the petitioning practices of the 18th-century Iroquois: (1) the expanding spatial arrangements of the Six Nations, (2) the confederacy politics of the Six Nations, including the emergence of pro-English versus pro-French factions within Iroquoia, (3) the emergence of new colonial institutions such as legislatures with committees, state councils and monarchical organizations, and (4) the growing use of petitions by other Native peoples in the Northeast and Great Lakes regions. The study relies on an original quantitative database of Iroquois requests and complaints, some newly utilized documents from the French archives, and a reinterpretation of the 1710 visit of the “Four Indians Kings” to Queen Anne.

Speaker Bio: Daniel Carpenter is Allie S. Freed Professor of Government, Director of the Center for American Political Studies in the Faculty of Arts and Sciences, and Director of the Social Science Academic Ventures Program at the Radcliffe Institute at Harvard University. In Spring 2014 he was a visiting professor at the École des Hautes Études en Sciences Sociales in Paris, France.  He taught previously at Princeton University (1995-1998) and the University of Michigan (1998-2002). He joined the Harvard University faculty in 2002.  Dr. Carpenter mixes theoretical, historical, statistical and mathematical analyses to examine the development of political institutions, particularly in the United States.  He focuses upon public bureaucracies and government regulation, particularly regulation of health and financial products.


Cosponsored with the Yale Group for the Study of Native America (YGSNA)


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *