Thủ Thiêm

Home | About | Phú Mỹ Hưng

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

The Thủ Thiêm New Urban Zone is an ambitious yet unfinished project located across the river from District 1, Ho Chi Minh City’s central business district and historic center. Even though Thủ Thiêm is often depicted as “empty” or “wild,” the project has entailed the eviction of over 14,000 households, as well as the demolition of scores of historic and religious buildings. While many of the evictees are recent migrants, the displaced households also include residents who trace their ancestors back to the area for more than three generations, longer than they can count.  Although few of the multi-generational households can pinpoint precisely when they came to Thủ Thiêm, the area has been populated by Vietnamese for as long as Saigon itself. The Thủ Thiêm market was established in 1751, and the Thủ Thiêm Catholic Church claims to be the oldest parish in Saigon.

Despite it’s rich history and its vibrant social life, Thủ Thiêm is often depicted as underdeveloped. Located just across the river from some of the most valuable real estate in Southeast Asia (if not Asia, and the world), planners and developers seek to completely “raze this area to nothing” (“giải tỏa trắng”) and aggressively engineer the area into developable land, literally forming a blank slate from which they can build anew. The site clearance and construction has almost completely evicted all of the residents from the area. The residents are forced to relocate to the fringe of the city and to learn how to adapt. Others had to return to their demolished homes and live in the rubble because they were not able to properly reintegrate back into society post-eviction. Many could not find a new location for their home or maintain their livelihood.

Studying eviction and land compensations issues in Thủ Thiêm reveals a complex relationship between residents and the Vietnamese state. The residents resist specific issues like evictions while displaying general enthusiasm for urban development as a whole.

Click here to read a brief history of Thủ Thiêm.

Click here for academic articles written by Dr. Erik Harms about evictions in Thủ Thiêm.

 


 

Thủ Thiêm Photos

In the Rubble
Relocation
Imagining the Future
Building and Construction

 

 

 

 

 

 


 

Thủ Thiêm Documents

Thủ Thiêm Online Newspaper Articles

 

Thủ Thiêm Interviews

Thủ Thiêm Selected Interviews

Phú Mỹ Hưng

Home | About | Thủ Thiêm

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

Phú Mỹ Hưng, also known as the Saigon South New Urban Zone, is located approximately 6 kilometers southwest of the historic center of Ho Chi Minh City. It is a master-planned mixed-use residential and commercial development filled with shopping and recreational centers, global business and conference facilities, and middle- to high-end residential housing. Developers designed Phú Mỹ Hưng with utopian visions of a modern and orderly city. The general ethos of the development is captured by Phú Mỹ Hưng’s official slogan: “Đô thị văn minh, cộng đồng nhân văn,”  which the Phú Mỹ Hưng Corporation has translated into English as “Civilization City, Human Oriented Community.”

In our research, we asked some very simple questions:

What is a “civilization city”?

“What is it like to live in an urban zone explicitly designed to foster “urban civilization”?

“How does living in a place like this change the people who live there?”

Through the course of in-depth ethnographic research with residents of Phú Mỹ Hưng, we discovered that the idea of “urban civilization” was a powerful organizing framework for their understanding of the new world they wanted to create by living in the new spatial world of Phú Mỹ Hưng. But we also learned that the interaction between the master-planned space and the people who live in it is not one-way. This New Urban Zone has not only transformed Vietnamese life, but Vietnamese modes of living in and experiencing urban life have transformed the original vision of the development.

The residence area is filled with condominiums, townhouses and shopping centers that transform everyday life for residents. There is no more space for “alleyway culture” in the new city. Families rarely interact spontaneously with their neighbors, even if they live next door to one another. Street cafes and sidewalk vendors no longer exist in the way they do in other parts of Ho Chi Minh City and elsewhere throughout Vietnam. But this does not mean that social life has disappeared; it simply takes new forms. In the New Urban Zone, friends do not meet for coffee at impromptu sidewalk cafes. Instead, they meet early in the morning to exercise, to play tennis, badminton, and to walk together around the open streets and through the exercise pathways in the area’s parks. At other times of the day, they meet at cafes and restaurants. While spontaneous visits to “drop by” people’s homes are increasingly rare, friends still invite invite each other to their houses.

It is a common perception that Phú Mỹ Hưng introduced an urban space that is controlled exclusively by elites–that it is an area reserved exclusively for “rich people.” This is partly true: access to the most expensive housing in the new urban zone is limited to those who can afford the high price of living, including Western and Asian expatriate business managers, well-situated overseas Vietnamese (Viet Kieu), and successful Vietnamese businesspeople. But there are also many middle-income Vietnamese who choose to rent or purchase smaller flats in some of the older and less-expensive apartment complexes. Even the cheapest housing in Phú Mỹ Hưng (several hundred dollars per-month for a two bedroom apartment in the oldest apartment complex) is certainly not affordable to all Vietnamese in the city. Other forms of housing include a mixture of older rental apartments, semi-detached residential housing, and row-houses with street-level storefronts, which complement the more exclusive high-end residences. Luxury condominiums, stand alone villas, and resort-like homes stand behind the security perimeter of walled-in gated communities.

Click here to read a brief history of Phú Mỹ Hưng.

 


Phú Mỹ Hưng Photos

Everyday Life
Built Landscape
Civilizing Dreams
Land and Capital

 

 

 

 

 

 

These photo galleries illustrate the interaction between utopian visions of the New Urban Zone, and the ways in which people inhabit it. The photos not only show how Phú Mỹ Hưng changes the people who live there, but also how they have changed Phú Mỹ Hưng.


 

Phú Mỹ Hưng Documents

Phú Mỹ Hưng Online Newspaper Articles

Phú Mỹ Hưng Interviews

Phú Mỹ Hưng Selected Interviews