WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 28, 2024

Location: Sterling Memorial Library Lecture Hall, 120 High Street, New Haven, CT

Pre-Conference Reception and Dinner for Program Participants Only: To be held on Tuesday evening, February 27; see details below.

TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 27, 2024
6:30-9:00 PM
Pre-Conference Reception and Dinner (only for participants on the conference schedule below)
The Study at Yale Hotel Penthouse, 1157 Chapel Street, New Haven, CT
WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 28, 2024
8:30-9:00 AM
Coffee and light continental breakfast available at the conference venue
Sterling Memorial Library Lecture Hall, 120 High Street, New Haven, CT
9:00-9:05 AM Introduction

  • Hélène Landemore, Professor of Political Science, Yale University; Distinguished Researcher, Oxford University Institute for Ethics in AI
9:05-10:45 AM Who Governed the French Conventions?

  • Sandrine Rui : “What Does Governing a Citizens’ Assembly Mean: Power and
    Contingency at the Citizens’ Convention on End of Life”
  • Jean-Michel Fourniau on the Citizens Convention for Climate (CCC): “Political Mandate and Governance of a Citizens’ Assembly”
  • Chloé Santoro: “Voting in a deliberative process: what, when, how to vote and who decides?”
  • Hélène Landemore and Théophile Pénigaud: “The case for self-ruling citizens’
    assemblies: Governance, Representation, and Citizen Leadership in the French
    Conventions.”
  • Reaction by Claire Thoury and Nathalie Berriau

Moderated by: Antonin Lacelle-Webster, Postdoctoral Associate with the Democratic Innovations Program at ISPS, Yale University

10:45-11:00 AM Coffee Break
11:00-12:40 PM Citizen Voice and Minorities Representation, and Leadership in the French Citizens’ Conventions

  • Christiane Rafidinarivo, “Representation of Minorities Within Citizens’ Assemblies: the Experience of the Citizens’ Convention for Climate”
  • Miguel Von Fedak “Stories of Discontent: Moments of Tension and Distrust in the
    French Convention on the End of Life”
  • Marjan Ehsassi, “Blueprint for Activated Citizenship: Designing for Legitimacy & Transformative Change
  • Reaction from online participants: Mathieu Sanchez (member of the Citizens Convention for Climate), Harry Alzire, Martial Breton, Soline Castel, and Léo Van Nieuwenhove (members of the Citizens’ Convention on End-of-Life Issues)

Moderated by: Jane Suiter, Professor of Political Communication at Dublin City University

12:40-2:00 PM Lunch Break
2:00-3:45 PM International Perspective on Citizens’ Assemblies and other Democratic Innovations Governance

  • Jane Suiter, “The Ongoing Internal Evolution of Citizens’ Assemblies in Ireland”
  • Antoine Vergne, “Governing Citizens’ Assemblies: A Reflective Approach Leading to Two Blueprints”
  • Min Reuchamps , “Governing Permanent Citizens’ Assemblies in Belgium”
  • Claire Mellier, “The 2021 Global Citizens’ Assembly on the climate and ecological crisis: A power-sensitive exploration of governance”
  • Reaction by Claudia Chwalisz and Gaëtane Ricard-Nihoul

Moderated by: Colin Scicluna, Head of Cabinet to the Vice President for Democracy & Demography, European Commission

3:45-4:00 PM Coffee Break
4:00-5:30 PM Roundtable: Should Citizens’ Assemblies be more like sovereign parliaments or not?

  • Thierry Beaudet, President of the French Economic, Social and Environmental Council
  • Cristina Lafont, Professor of Philosophy at Northwestern University
  • Hélène Landemore, Professor of Political Science, Yale University; Distinguished Researcher, Oxford University Institute for Ethics in AI
  • Myriam Souami, Member of the Citizens’ Convention on End-of-Life Issues

Moderated by: Alexandra Cirone, Assistant Professor of Government at Cornell University and Visiting fellow at the Yale Institution for Social and Policy Studies

6:30 – 9:00 PM Conference Dinner and Welcome Reception (only for specially invited guests from both conferences)

THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 29, 2024 – Overlapping with the “Governing (with) AI” Conference until 12:40 PM

Location: Sterling Memorial Library Lecture Hall, 120 High Street, New Haven, CT

The following is the working schedule for overlapping portion between Governing (with) AI and Governing Citizens Assemblies, taking place on the morning of February 29th. The event will be structured as collaborative working sessions.

The agenda is being designed as a combination of planned sessions and emergent participant-driven discussions, and specific topics will be placed into time slots based on input at the meeting from those in attendance. Sessions will be dialog- and outcome-oriented rather than presentations or lecture format.

For more information about the workshop format, please visit our page on the agenda overview and guidelines

THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 29
8:30-9:00 AM
Coffee and light continental breakfast available at the conference venue
Sterling Memorial Library Lecture Hall, 120 High Street, New Haven, CT
9:00 – 9:30 AM Opening Session

The event will be called to order with a friendly and fast-paced kickoff that includes words of welcome from the hosts, brief participant introductions, along with overviews of the agenda, participation guidelines and meeting logistics.

9:30 – 10:45 AM Surveying the Potential for Augmenting Democratic Governance Using AI

The program will begin with a series of interactive learning dialogues that explore selected facets at the intersection of AI and democratic governance. Participants will be invited to rotate between topics across the course of the session.

  • The role of AI in deliberative democracy
  • Can a chatbot facilitate deliberation?
  • Using AI to synthesize a collective will
  • The tools of governance (as opposed to government)
  • Privacy and security issues in the use of AI in democratic processes
  • Adversarial uses of AI in democracy
  • Applying a power analysis to AI
10:45 – 11:00 AM Break
11:00 AM – 12:30 PM Defining and Debugging AI Use Cases in Democratic Governance

The second half of the morning will focus on deeper discovery and problem articulation,
designed to inform subsequent strategy and design sessions.

  • Mapping use cases for AI in citizens assemblies
  • Inventorying the bugs of citizen assemblies that AI might solve
  • The advantages and disadvantages of AI facilitated deliberation
  • Open problems in using AI tools to connect citizens’ assemblies to the macro-public
  • Enumerating and comparing design patterns for global deliberation
  • Employing AI to enhance citizen participation in international dispute resolution on collective rights
  • Barriers and opportunities for the use of LLMs and chatbots in democratic deliberation outside the English-speaking world
  • Towards a threat model of AI in democratic contexts
12:30 – 1:30 PM Lunch

Participants are encouraged to dine with those who they have not yet met or engaged.

This is the end of the overlap between the “Governing Citizens’ Assemblies” conference and the “Governing (with) AI” conference. Invited guests from both conferences are welcome to stay for lunch. Invited guests from “Governing Citizens’ Assemblies” are free to depart Yale.

To participants staying for the entire “Governing (with) AI” Conference: please check the full schedule at this link.